Johanna Billing: Each Moment Presents What Happens

24 Mar-6 May 2023
PV 23 Mar 2023, 6-8pm


Hollybush Gardens is pleased to present Johanna Billing’s recent moving image work, Each Moment Presents What Happens (2021). This collaborative project reimagines Untitled Event (Theatre piece number 1, 1952) by John Cage — the first known happening or multimedia art work held in Black Mountain College, USA. The film records students mostly from Bristol Grammar School, UK, engaging in an experimental, improvisational and multidisciplinary process open to failure, exchange, and imagination. Each Moment continues Billing’s long-held examination of performance by creating a fictive space within a documentary premise, exploring the generative relation between actual and contrived events. 

Each Moment was commissioned by Bristol Grammar School to commemorate the opening of the 1532 Performing Arts Centre, connecting artistic departments in the school as well as the new theatre and wider audiences in the local area. In the film, the new centre is seen in the context of the School’s historic building facades, its grounds and great hall. Testing the differences between educational systems and what qualifies as knowledge, the project creates a dialogue between the School, founded in 1532, now selective, independent and fee-paying and the defunct Black Mountain College, founded in 1933, specialising in liberal arts education. Cage’s Untitled Event was originally held in the dining hall of Black Mountain College and although Cage arranged time slots, the event was primarily informed by chance with activities taking place simultaneously. The event featured dance, painting, music, film, live readings and performance created by Merce Cunningham, Franz Kline, David Tudor, Robert Rauschenberg, Nicolas Cernovtich, MC Richards, Charles Olsson and John Cage. 

In lieu of photographic or video documentation, the original happening lives on today through memories and audience testimonies. These contradictory recollections, gaps in historical revision and the anonymity of Cage’s content serve as a point of departure for the students. Experimenting across disciplines, Billing encourages a practical and poetic approach to learning, which challenges the values of failure and success, process and outcome. Collectively, the students were invited to imagine what could have taken place around, before, during and after the event, articulating responses through dance, music, theatre, poetry, painting, philosophy, photography, dj-ing and film production. The project thus advocates a means of thinking the past through the personal, coincidental and relational. The work’s title directly quotes Cage’s Lecture on Nothing (1959), which becomes a poignant motif throughout the film. The performers recite this titular lecture as well as Cage’s Lecture on Something (1951) alongside poems written themselves. By revisiting Cage’s historical texts, the performers consider the meaning of improvisation, success, authorship and artistic autonomy in relation to everyday experience and chance events. 

Each Moment features a reconsideration of Cage’s Prepared Piano Pieces (1938-54). Originally, the act
of preparation was designed to contort the instrument’s sound by inserting bolts, screws, erasers and other objects between the piano strings. In this, Cage sought ‘to place in the hands of a single pianist the equivalent of an entire percussion orchestra’ with the prepared piano serving as a precursor to his later experiments with chance. In the film, students collect material across departments, inserting a myriad of objects such as toys, art utensils, cutlery, science equipment and office stationary. Notably, Cage’s Prepared Piano Pieces had been removed from the A Level music syllabus as the work’s ambivalent status challenged conventional academic assessment. Billing’s revival of this exercise, however, sees the instrument function as a site of collective ownership and cross-disciplinary creation. 

Formally, Each Moment is distinguished by its attentive negotiation of time. Taking place over a single day, the work’s sensitivity to the passing and structuring of time is redoubled by a self-reflexive approach to the camera. Students are variously recorded preparing work, speaking publicly in the dining hall, and playing the piano — all are parallel performances embedded within the reality of the school day. Correlational performances occur within the black box theatre, recorded by a camera installed upon a track in a 360 degree formation. The lens observes the students’ action and the supporting film crew in a circular orbit. This recording structure relates to Cage’s original event in which performers framed the audience, themselves seated centrally and facing outward — each viewer observing different activity.

In Each Moment, the camera functions as both participant and structuring device, offering a viewpoint in the round which acknowledges peripheral action. The students interchange their handling of the camera, allowing the speed of recording to be determined by the body. In permitting a different activity to enter after a number of rotations, the camera becomes an imperfect device to organise time while formally resembling a clock face or timepiece. By physically relating to the camera’s movements in space, the students become conscious of ‘keeping time’ only through a dynamic estimation and felt sense of its very passing. Each Moment deconstructs the conception of recorded time as simply a line, limit or mark, the circularity becomes symbolic and encourages a thinking of time as a gyre, unsteady and oscillatory.